亚洲中文字幕日产无码2020,国产精品186在线观看在线播放,久久婷婷五月综合色99啪ak,国产精品麻豆aⅴ人妻

Unitalen Represented a Case of Unfair Competition Disputes between a Shanghai X Lian (Group) Co., Ltd., a Shanghai X Lian (Group) Co., Ltd. WU X Cai Eyeglasses Company vs. Nanjing WU X Cai Eyeglasses Co., Ltd.

December 19, 2024

Case Brief

In 1807, WU X Cai transformed the "Chengmingzhai Jewelry and Jade Shop" established in Shanghai in 1719, which also operated an eyeglasses business, into WU X Cai Eyeglasses Store specializing in the eyeglasses business. In 1926, the store was renamed WU X Cai Eyeglasses Company, and in October 1998, it was renamed Shanghai X Lian (Group) Co., Ltd. WU X Cai Eyeglasses Company (hereinafter referred to as Shanghai WU X Cai Company). In 1947, the WU X Cai Eyeglasses Company Nanjing Branch was registered and established. However, due to historical reasons, Shanghai WU X Cai Company and Nanjing WU X Cai Eyeglasses Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as Nanjing WU X Cai Company) are no longer affiliated. Since 1989, the X Lian Group and Shanghai WU X Cai Company have successively registered multiple "吳良材" word trademarks, which have gained high market recognition after long-term use and were recognized as well-known trademarks in 2004. In 2015, X Lian Group and Shanghai WU X Cai Company discovered that Nanjing WU X Cai Company and its branches, authorized franchisees used the enterprise name and logo containing the words "吳良材" in their registration and operation and claimed that "Nanjing WU X Cai Eyeglasses was developed from the Nanjing branch of Shanghai WU X Cai Eyeglasses Company", and they conducted group buying on Dianping.com. The X Lian Group and Shanghai WU X Cai Company believe that Nanjing WU X Cai Company constitutes trademark infringement and unfair competition, and therefore request the court to order the cessation of infringement, elimination of impact, and compensation for losses and reasonable expenses.

Result of Ruling

The first instance court ruled that Nanjing WU X Cai Company shall cease trademark infringement and unfair competition, immediately cease using logos containing the words "吳良材" by authorizing franchisees in the franchise operations, immediately cease registering and using enterprise names containing the words "吳良材" outside of Nanjing, Jiangsu Province by its branches, eliminate the impact, and compensate for economic losses of RMB 2.6 million. With dissatisfaction, Nanjing WU X Cai Company appealed against the first instance judgment.

Shanghai Intellectual Property Court, taking into account factors such as history, current situation, and fairness, believes: Firstly, Nanjing WU X Cai Company has a particular historical connection with the historical WU X Cai Eyeglasses Company. Nanjing WU X Cai Company registered and used an enterprise name containing the words "吳良材" before the registration time of the involved trademark, so it does not constitute unfair competition. However, although Nanjing WU X Cai Company and Shanghai WU X Cai Company have a particular historical connection with the historical WU X Cai Eyeglasses Company, they have no affiliation with each other. In the case where the trademark "吳良材" of Shanghai WU X Cai Company has already gained high reputation and has been recognized as a well-known trademark, whereas Nanjing WU X Cai Company has no nationwide recognition, Nanjing WU X Cai Company extensively developed franchised stores nationwide from 2004 to 2015, authorized these franchise stores to use enterprise names containing the words "吳良材", claimed in external promotions that it was a "century-old store", concealed the fact that it was not associated with Shanghai WU X Cai Company, and falsely claimed to be the Nanjing branch of Shanghai WU X Cai Company. These behaviors intended to take advantage of the goodwill of Shanghai WU X Cai Company and mislead consumers. Without appropriate restrictions on the scope of use of its enterprise name, it would be difficult to prevent market confusion and insufficient to protect the interests of trademark owners. Therefore, it is reasonable to limit the geographical scope of Nanjing WU X Cai Company's branches registered with enterprise names containing the words "吳良材" to within the Nanjing area. Secondly, although Nanjing WU X Cai Company, as the prior user of the enterprise name, has the right to continue using its enterprise name itself, the corresponding scope of the subject should also be limited; that is, it should not permit others to register or use enterprise names and logos containing the words "吳良材". Therefore, Nanjing WU X Cai Company's authorization to franchisees to use enterprise names and logos containing the phrase "吳良材" constitutes trademark infringement and unfair competition; the use of the words "吳良材" by Nanjing WU X Cai Company, its branches, and franchisees also constitutes trademark infringement. Thirdly, by presenting a partial and incomplete narrative of being a "century-old store," Nanjing WU X Cai Company misled the relevant public through concealment and false statements into believing that it has an association with Shanghai WU X Cai Company, maliciously taking advantage of the goodwill of Shanghai WU X Cai Company. This behavior constitutes false advertising. In summary, the second instance judgment rejected the appeal and upheld the original ruling.

Typical Significance

The ruling in this case has appropriately addressed the issue of commercial identification conflicts left over by history. It provides specific ruling and guiding significance for regulating the use of "time-honored brands," promoting honest business practices among market entities, preventing market confusion, and safeguarding the legitimate interests of consumers.

 

Keywords

主站蜘蛛池模板: 中文在线а√在线| 亚洲精品国产aⅴ成拍色拍| 69国产成人精品午夜福中文| 亚洲精品久久久www| 人人妻人人爽人人澡欧美一区 | 色欲久久九色一区二区三区 | 国产成人亚洲综合二区| 久久久久人妻一区二区三区vr| 亚洲综合伊人久久综合| 狠狠躁天天躁中文字幕| 亚洲婷婷开心色四房播播| 一边啪啪一边呻吟av夜夜嗨| 国产精品网站在线观看免费传媒| 伊人久久大香线蕉综合直播| 欧美乱人伦中文字幕在线| 玩弄丰满少妇人妻视频| 两性色午夜视频免费老司机| 国产成人综合在线视频| 天堂а√中文最新版地址在线| 国产亚洲成av片在线观看| 国产欧美现场va另类| 欧美亚洲日韩不卡在线在线观看| 亚洲国产精品一区二区www| 成人aaa片一区国产精品| 免费高清欧美一区二区三区| 精品无码av不卡一区二区三区| 久99久精品免费视频热| 丰满的少妇愉情hd高清果冻传媒| 欧美三级欧美成人高清| 亚洲欧洲日韩综合久久| 欧美va天堂va视频va在线| 草色噜噜噜av在线观看香蕉| 天天躁日日躁狠狠躁婷婷高清| 亚洲国产天堂久久综合226114 | 欧洲熟妇色xxxx欧美老妇多毛网站 | 中国熟妇内谢69xxxxx| 国产精品久久二区二区| 无套内谢少妇免费| 中文字幕在线亚洲日韩6页| 国产9色在线 | 日韩| 一日本道伊人久久综合影|