亚洲中文字幕日产无码2020,国产精品186在线观看在线播放,久久婷婷五月综合色99啪ak,国产精品麻豆aⅴ人妻

Chinese “Lafite” Mark Recognized as an Unregistered Well-known Mark by Shanghai IP Court

June 4, 2018

On December 27, 2017, Shanghai IP Court issued a judgement over the dispute between Chateau Lafite Rothschild (“Lafite”) vs. Shanghai Baochun Industrial Development Co. Ltd.(“Baochun”) and Shanghai Safe Logistics Supply Chains Management P.L.C. (“Safe Logistics”) for trademark infringement. Based on the recognition of 拉菲 (LAFITE in Chinese) as a unregistered well-known mark, the court affirmed the similarity between the plaintiff’s marks and the accused infringing marks, namely 拉菲 vs 拉菲特 and LAFITE vs MORON LAFITE, and the constitution of trademark infringement. In consideration of the reputation and distinctiveness of the plaintiff’s trademarks, the malicious intention of the defendants, the sales scale of the infringing products, as well as the huge difference between the import price and retail price of the infringing products, the court ordered the two defendants pay a joint damage of RMB 2 million yuan to compensate the plaintiff’s losses and publish a statement to eliminate the impact.

 

This case involves three challenging issues:

 

1) The plaintiff’s 拉菲 mark was not registered when the accused infringement occurred, but was then approved for registration during the trial. Is it still necessary to determine whether it’s an unregistered well-known trademark under such case?

 

2) When the accused infringement occurred, there was another registered mark “拉菲莊園” which however became invalid during the trial of this case. Was the accused mark 拉菲特莊園 infringing on the then registered trademark拉菲莊園or the then unregistered well-known trademark拉菲?

 

3) The accused infringing products were indeed imported from a French winery “CHATEAU MORON LAFITTE”, which is a registered mark in France. How to balance the territorial principle of trademark registration and the requirement for imported wines displaying genuine information.

 

With regard to the necessity of recognizing the unregistered well-known trademark, the court held that, although the plaintiff's 拉菲 was preliminarily published on January 27, 2014, the opposition thereto was not dismissed until February 2017. According to Article 36 of Trademark Law, the plaintiff cannot enjoy any retroactive rights against the use of marks that are identical with or similar to its mark by others. In addition, the accused infringement acts occurred before the plaintiff acquiring the exclusive right of the 拉菲 mark. For both reasons, the court considers it necessary to determine whether the plaintiff’s拉菲 mark was entitled an unregistered well-known mark at the time when the accused infringement act took place.

 

With regard to the impact of the other registered trademark 拉菲莊園 on this case, because it had been declared as invalid by the time when this judgement was made, it should be deemed as never valid from the beginning. In other words, there is no need to discuss the “rights” or “scopes of rights” of a trademark that never exists.

 

As to the co-existence of two parties’ marks and trade names in other country, the court explicitly states the territorial principle of trademark registration and emphasizes that the determination of trademark infringement shall be made independently in accordance with the Trademark Law of China, even though the two parties’ marks have co-existed in France. Besides, the French registered mark cited by the defendants is “CHATEAU MORON LAFITTE APPELATION BORDEAUX SUPERIEUR CONTROLEE” in handwriting style, whereas the trademark actually used on the alleged infringing products highlighted the “MORON LAFITTE” part and has a higher level of similarity to the plaintiff’s LAFITE” mark.

 

Keywords

主站蜘蛛池模板: 精品国产一卡2卡3卡4卡新区 | 国产亚洲精品久久久久久小说| 欧美人与物videos另类| 久久综合给综合给久久| 国产成人亚洲综合网色欲网 | 亚洲乱码中文字幕小综合| 96亚洲精华国产精华精华液| 精品乱码一区二区三区四区| 内射一区二区精品视频在线观看| 人妻少妇精品一区二区三区| 国产亚洲日韩在线aaaa| 国产午夜成人免费看片app| 97午夜理论片影院在线播放| 日本国产成人国产在线播放| 亚洲日产无码中文字幕| 国产成人18黄网站| 国产av无码久久精品| 国产女厕所盗摄老师厕所嘘嘘| 在线无码视频观看草草视频| 中文字幕无码人妻少妇免费| 色欲天天天综合网| 久久亚洲精品无码av| 暖暖免费 高清 日本社区在线观看| 亚洲最大无码av网站观看| 国产av无码专区影视| 成人无码视频在线观看大全| 永久免费的无码中文字幕| 日韩av无码精品一二三区| 欧美日韩一区二区免费视频| 婷婷激情综合色五月久久竹菊影视| 免费人成在线观看播放a| 精品久久久久中文字幕一区| 中日韩亚洲人成无码网站| 国产成人av大片在线观看| 白嫩少妇激情无码| 无遮挡啪啪摇乳动态图gif| 日韩精品亚洲人成在线| 国产做爰xxxⅹ久久久| 欧美午夜精品久久久久免费视| 亚洲午夜精品a片久久www慈禧| 亚洲国内精品自在线影院牛牛|